top of page

TIPP vs TOPP | SAICA Articles.

Embarking on a career as a CA(SA) in South Africa begins with completing a three-year SAICA articles programme after university. The South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (SAICA) offers two primary paths: the Training Outside Public Practice (TOPP) programme and the Training Inside Public Practice (TIPP) programme. We have delved into these two choices, exploring their similarities, differences, and potential advantages to help aspiring professionals make an informed decision.

Graphic comparing TIPP to. TOPP SAICA Article Programmes. Compare the training inside public practice with the training outside public practice. Understand the benefits and considerations for aspiring CAs.

Understanding TIPP.

The Training Inside Public Practice (TIPP) programme is designed for individuals who aim to pursue their training within an auditing firm, typically referred to as a registered training office. Key features of TIPP include:

  • Practical Experience: TIPP exposes trainees to real-world scenarios, allowing them to develop a solid understanding of auditing and accounting principles.

  • Structured Learning: TIPP combines on-the-job training with formal classroom sessions, providing a structured approach to professional development.

  • Mentorship: Trainees in TIPP receive guidance and support from experienced professionals within the auditing firm, aiding in their overall growth and learning.


Unraveling TOPP.

The Training Outside Public Practice (TOPP) programme caters to individuals who prefer to gain their training experience in the commercial and industrial sector rather than an auditing firm. TOPP offers the following key aspects:

  • Diverse Experience: TOPP trainees work in various industries, and on various projects, including finance, banking, retail, service and more, broadening their exposure beyond auditing.

  • Multidisciplinary Learning: TOPP equips trainees with a comprehensive understanding of accounting and finance, enabling them to develop a versatile skill set.

  • Business Insight: TOPP provides insights into the inner workings of different industries, enabling trainees to comprehend the broader business landscape.


Key Similarities.

While TIPP and TOPP differ in their training environments, they share some essential similarities:

  • SAICA Accreditation: Both TIPP and TOPP are SAICA-accredited training programmes, ensuring that graduates are equipped with the necessary skills and knowledge required by the accounting profession.

  • Professional Qualification: Successful completion of either programme leads to eligibility for the rigorous Assessment of Professional Competence (APC), the final step towards becoming a Chartered Accountant (CA) in South Africa.

  • Practical Experience: Both TIPP and TOPP place a significant emphasis on gaining practical experience, allowing trainees to apply theoretical concepts in real-world scenarios.

In summary, both paths result in your qualification as a CA(SA), and the same board exam is written, irrespective of your chosen path.


Advantages of TIPP:

Advantages of TOPP:

Specialized Expertise: TIPP focuses primarily on auditing and related fields, providing trainees with in-depth knowledge and experience in this specific domain.

Industry Versatility: TOPP exposes trainees to a diverse range of industries, providing them with a broader understanding of the business landscape.

Industry Exposure: Trainees in TIPP work closely with auditing professionals, allowing them to build valuable networks within the auditing and accounting industry.

Enhanced Business Acumen: Trainees in TOPP develop a holistic perspective, gaining insights into financial management, strategic planning, and operational processes in various sectors.

Well-Defined Career Path: TIPP is often seen as the traditional route for aspiring Chartered Accountants, offering a clear career progression within auditing firms.

Networking Opportunities: Working in different industries through TOPP allows trainees to build a diverse professional network, which can prove valuable throughout their careers.


Wrapping it Up.

Choosing between TIPP and TOPP for your SAICA training programme is a decision that depends on your individual career aspirations and preferences. TIPP offers specialized expertise and a well-defined career path within auditing firms, while TOPP provides industry versatility and enhanced business acumen. Regardless of your choice, both programmes offer a solid foundation for becoming a Chartered Accountant in South Africa. Evaluate your goals, interests, and long-term plans to make an informed decision that aligns with your professional aspirations.

If you’re unsure of which route is best for you, why not check out our articles aptitude test, to see where you might be best suited.


bottom of page